Is a Hacker News Show HN worth it? Real numbers from founders

Hacker News has a peculiar place in the SaaS founder's launch playbook. It's uncontrollable in a way that most channels aren't — you can prepare carefully, pick good timing, write a great top comment, and still land on page three with 18 points. You can also post on a random Tuesday morning and find yourself on the front page by noon.

Understanding the realistic distribution of outcomes is the first step to using the channel intelligently.

Quick answer: A Show HN is worth doing for developer tools, security products, and technically interesting products — front-page posts drive 5,000–20,000+ visitors and leave a permanent DR 91 backlink from news.ycombinator.com. Most posts land at 10–50 points and drive only a few dozen visits, but the cost is an afternoon and the upside is asymmetric enough to justify the attempt.

What do the numbers look like for a real Show HN?

The range of outcomes for a Show HN is wide. At the low end, posts that don't gain early traction settle with 10–50 points and receive a few dozen visits over 24 hours. At the mid-range, a post that breaks into the top 30 on the new page and sustains engagement can reach 100–300 points and drive 500–2,000 unique visitors in the first day. At the high end, a post that makes the front page and stays there for several hours — particularly if it generates substantive discussion — can drive 5,000 to 20,000+ unique visitors.

The distribution is heavily skewed. Most Show HN posts are in the low range. Front-page posts are a small minority. You cannot reliably predict which category your post will fall into in advance.

What you can observe from the pattern of successful posts: products that solve a problem the HN audience personally recognises (developer tools, productivity tools, security products, infrastructure), presented by founders who write well and engage honestly in the thread, tend to perform in the upper half of the range.

What happens to the traffic after day one?

The primary traffic spike is almost entirely in the first 24 hours, with a secondary but much smaller wave in days two and three as the thread ages and is discovered through search. After that, direct traffic from the HN post drops to near zero.

The lasting value is the HN thread's presence in Google search results. When someone searches your product name, an active HN thread is typically one of the top results — this is valuable social proof that compounds over time. The thread also contributes a backlink from news.ycombinator.com (DR 91+), which is one of the higher-authority domains you're likely to get a link from in the first year of your product's life.

For products that convert HN visitors into early users, those users tend to be exceptionally high-quality: technical, opinionated, and willing to provide detailed feedback. Several well-known SaaS products trace their first critical mass of power users back to a Show HN post.

Who does Show HN work best for?

Developer tools, security products, AI infrastructure, productivity tools for technical users, and anything that involves an interesting technical implementation. The HN audience is sophisticated and rewards genuine engineering. A product that does something technically impressive or solves a hard problem in an elegant way will get disproportionate attention.

Products that struggle on HN: consumer apps without a technical angle, B2B tools targeting non-technical buyers, and products in categories the HN community tends to be sceptical of (certain marketing tools, crypto/NFT projects, anything that reads as hype-driven).

The product maturity level matters less than you might think. HN is actually tolerant of rough MVPs if the underlying idea is strong. What they're intolerant of is polish covering up a weak idea.

Is it worth doing even if it might not land?

Yes — the cost is low if you're already building and writing. A Show HN post requires a good title, a solid top comment, and your presence in the thread for the first few hours. If you're already going to launch anyway, adding Show HN to the mix costs an afternoon.

The risk-adjusted return is positive even accounting for the variance. A mid-range post drives meaningful traffic and generates real user feedback. A front-page post can be genuinely life-changing for an early-stage product. A low-performing post costs you a few hours and leaves a permanent HN backlink on your domain. That's a reasonable bet.

---

Built something? Submit your product to LaunchBuff → — free listing + fortnightly tournament.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you get shadowbanned on Hacker News? Yes. HN has mechanisms for penalising accounts that violate community norms — vote manipulation, excessive self-promotion, low-quality comments. Accounts that are shadowbanned don't know they're banned; their posts simply don't appear to others. Build a real HN account history before your launch post.

Should I tell my network to upvote the Show HN? Asking people who would genuinely find your product interesting to check it out is fine. Explicitly asking for upvotes is against HN rules and detectable. The difference matters: "check out my Show HN post and let me know what you think" is legitimate, "go upvote my Show HN post" is vote manipulation.

What's the best way to write the top comment for a Show HN? Keep it to two to three paragraphs. Explain what you built and why (not in marketing language — in plain technical terms). Share something honest about the process: a hard problem you solved, a tradeoff you made, something you're uncertain about. End by explicitly asking for feedback. Invite criticism. The community respects founders who engage honestly.

Is a Show HN better than a Product Hunt launch? They serve different purposes and have different audiences. HN is technical, critical, and rewards depth. PH is broader, more social, and rewards polish. For technical products, HN often drives higher-quality early users despite potentially lower total traffic. Doing both is better than choosing.